Excessive Workload, Anxiety, and Student Success: A Comprehensive Review

Introduction

High school students today often face excessive academic workloads – long hours of class assignments and homework – that can overwhelm even the most diligent learners. Educators and researchers are increasingly concerned about the toll this heavy load takes on student well-being and academic success, especially for those with chronic anxiety. This report reviews empirical evidence from the U.S. and abroad on how an overloaded schedule of classwork and homework can negatively affect high schoolers’ academic performance and mental health. It also highlights findings specific to students who struggle with anxiety, and examines evidence-based arguments for reducing or modifying workloads to better support these students. Key findings are summarized under clear themes below, with references to original research.

Academic Overload and Student Stress

Multiple studies have documented that too much homework and classwork contribute to high stress levels and related health problems in teens. In a well-known survey of 4,317 students at high-performing U.S. high schools, 56% of students cited homework as a primary stressor (exceeding stress from tests or grades) (Stanford research shows pitfalls of homework | Stanford Report). Many reported chronic sleep deprivation, headaches, weight loss, and other health issues, which they attributed to heavy homework loads (Stanford research shows pitfalls of homework | Stanford Report). On average these students were doing 3+ hours of homework per night, an amount researchers found was counterproductive beyond a certain point (Homework Wars: High School Workloads, Student Stress, and How Parents Can Help | The Princeton Review) (Homework Wars: High School Workloads, Student Stress, and How Parents Can Help | The Princeton Review). As Stanford researcher Denise Pope noted, “too much homework resulted in stress, physical health problems and a general lack of balance” in students’ lives (Homework Wars: High School Workloads, Student Stress, and How Parents Can Help | The Princeton Review). Such imbalances mean less time for family, friends, and extracurriculars, and are linked to burnout and disengagement (Stanford research shows pitfalls of homework | Stanford Report) (Stanford research shows pitfalls of homework | Stanford Report).

Importantly, the issue is not limited to the U.S. A global pattern is observed: A recent systematic review reported that in 48 out of 52 studies worldwide, high academic pressure correlated with poorer adolescent mental health outcomes ( Contributing Factors to the Rise in Adolescent Anxiety and Associated Mental Health Disorders: A Narrative Review of Current Literature – PMC ). For example, studies in China and Greece found that students facing heavy academic pressure were significantly more likely to suffer from anxiety disorders ( Contributing Factors to the Rise in Adolescent Anxiety and Associated Mental Health Disorders: A Narrative Review of Current Literature – PMC ). These findings underscore that an overload of academic work – whether through excessive homework, a crammed class schedule, or relentless exam prep – can push teens into unhealthy levels of stress in many different cultural contexts.

The modern high school experience often combines packed daily schedules with substantial homework at night. In affluent, high-achieving schools especially, students juggle advanced classes, AP courses, and extracurricular commitments that extend into the evening. Education expert Cathy Vatterott describes how “excessive workloads, crammed schedules, and ‘perfectionism’ are causing teens undue stress” (The Teens Are Not Alright). She notes that in many “pressure-cooker” school environments, rigor is wrongly equated with piling on more work, and “students are overwhelmed [and] overworked” (The Teens Are Not Alright). Ironically, those high-pressure schools where nearly every student is college-bound often have the largest split between students with no homework and those with very heavy homework burdens (Homework Wars: High School Workloads, Student Stress, and How Parents Can Help | The Princeton Review). In other words, a subset of high schoolers are doing an extraordinary amount of work – and it is this group that reports the highest stress. Surveys find over 70% of students are often or always stressed about schoolwork, and homework is the number one source of stress for about a quarter of teens (Homework Wars: High School Workloads, Student Stress, and How Parents Can Help | The Princeton Review) (Does Homework Cause Stress? Exploring the Impact on Students’ Mental Health – Healium). Clearly, academic overload is a pervasive stressor in the high school population.

Mental Health Consequences: Anxiety and Burnout

One of the most concerning effects of excessive academic workload is its impact on mental health, particularly in triggering or exacerbating anxiety disorders. High school is already a period when many adolescents experience anxiety, and adding an overwhelming workload can intensify these symptoms. Research published in 2023 and 2024 has strengthened our understanding of this link:

In summary, overwhelming classwork and homework loads can precipitate chronic anxiety, depression, and burnout in teenagers. Those who already have anxiety disorders are particularly vulnerable – they experience the stress more intensely and are at higher risk of adverse outcomes (like school avoidance or breakdowns). It bears emphasizing that these mental health impacts directly impede academic engagement: as one school psychologist explains, “learning and mental health are really intertwined… when students are struggling with anxiety or depression, their ability to listen, remember, and perform in class is compromised” (Students Are Missing School Because They’re Too Anxious to Show Up). The next section examines how this dynamic affects academic success indicators for anxious vs. non-anxious students.

Academic Performance under Heavy Workloads: Anxious vs. Non-Anxious Students

Excessive workload not only affects mental health, but can also undermine academic success – especially for students prone to anxiety. While a certain amount of challenge can motivate students, pushing them beyond their coping capacity often backfires. Research reveals a nuanced picture of how heavy classwork/homework loads influence grades, test performance, and other outcomes, and how anxious students may be differently impacted:

In aggregate, these findings paint a clear picture: excessive classwork and homework loads tend to hurt, not help, student success, and students with chronic anxiety are often the first to feel these negative effects. Heavy workloads contribute to anxiety, and high anxiety in turn is linked to poorer academic outcomes (from lower grades to higher dropout risk) (Association between anxiety, depression symptoms, and academic burnout among Chinese students: the mediating role of resilience and self-efficacy | BMC Psychology | Full Text) (Association between anxiety, depression symptoms, and academic burnout among Chinese students: the mediating role of resilience and self-efficacy | BMC Psychology | Full Text). The good news is that studies also indicate this is a modifiable problem – meaning that by adjusting workload and support, schools can improve both well-being and academic results. The next section examines evidence that reducing or optimizing workload can benefit students, especially those with anxiety.

Benefits of Reducing or Modifying Workloads for Anxious Students

Research increasingly supports the idea that “less can be more” when it comes to promoting success in students with anxiety. By reducing unnecessary or excessive classwork and homework, schools may alleviate toxic stress while maintaining rigorous learning. Several evidence-based arguments and findings underscore why a more balanced approach to workload is effective:

Conclusion

Excessive classwork and homework at the high school level can undermine both well-being and academic success, and the risks are especially pronounced for students with chronic anxiety. The research reviewed here – spanning U.S. high schools to international settings – paints a consistent picture: when academic workload overwhelms, students experience high stress, diminished learning, and mental health crises. Anxious students serve as the “canary in the coal mine,” showing symptoms first and most intensely, but they are not the only ones affected. Unfortunately, the traditional assumption that “more work = more learning” is not supported by evidence beyond a moderate point (Frontiers | How to better balance academic achievement and learning anxiety from time on homework? A multilevel and classification and regression tree analyses) (Frontiers | How to better balance academic achievement and learning anxiety from time on homework? A multilevel and classification and regression tree analyses). Instead, overload can trigger anxiety that interferes with memory, focus, and motivation, ultimately reducing the quality of student work and engagement (A Systematic Review: Academic Anxiety in School-Aged Students) (Does Homework Cause Stress? Exploring the Impact on Students’ Mental Health – Healium).

However, the evidence also offers hope. Studies suggest that by rebalancing workloads – assigning purposeful homework in reasonable amounts, coordinating major assignments, and making time for students’ recovery and growth – schools can cultivate better outcomes. Students learn more deeply when they are not chronically anxious and exhausted. For those with anxiety disorders, thoughtful workload management and supportive strategies (like flexible deadlines or reduced course-load during high-stress periods) can enable them to thrive academically alongside their peers. In one telling statistic, over a third of high school students say that stress about homework hurts their mental health (Students Are Missing School Because They’re Too Anxious to Show Up) (Students Are Missing School Because They’re Too Anxious to Show Up); addressing this is thus a concrete lever to improve youth well-being.

Educators and consultants can take away a clear message: reducing excessive classwork and homework is not about “coddling” students, but about removing barriers to success. It is an evidence-based approach to help anxious learners unlock their capabilities. As one team of researchers concluded in a review of academic pressure, “high academic demands are having negative impacts on youth mental health” and it is imperative to find a healthier balance ( Contributing Factors to the Rise in Adolescent Anxiety and Associated Mental Health Disorders: A Narrative Review of Current Literature – PMC ) ( Contributing Factors to the Rise in Adolescent Anxiety and Associated Mental Health Disorders: A Narrative Review of Current Literature – PMC ). By heeding this evidence – through policies that prioritize quality over quantity in schoolwork – we can foster an environment where all students, including those with chronic anxiety, have the best chance to succeed academically and enjoy psychological well-being. In sum, a saner workload is a win-win: healthier minds and better learning outcomes.

References (Selected)

(Additional sources and studies are cited in-text above (Stanford research shows pitfalls of homework | Stanford Report) ( Contributing Factors to the Rise in Adolescent Anxiety and Associated Mental Health Disorders: A Narrative Review of Current Literature – PMC ), etc., to support specific points.)

Unknown's avatar

About drshannonrobinson

Life Coach, Christian Counselor, Education Consultant, Reading Specialist, Literacy Coach, Behavior Specialist for Children and Teens with Emotional/Behavioral/ADHD (36 years Experience); Wife, Mom, NaNa, Sister, Friend Teacher; Love Reading, Gardening, Cooking, Home Decor, Beach, Make-Up, Fashion, PUBLISHED CHILDREN'S BOOK: The Adventures of Katie Koala: Oops! My Momma is Lost.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a comment